I've never been a fan of BB and I live and work surrounded by RIM and their employees. They feel very utilitarian. I want a device I enjoy using. If it was only for work, then I would probably go with a BB. Android seems too fragmented to me. I read to many stories of people buying devices that are immediately obsolete and incompatible with the newest or next OS update. Also, while I appreciate the openness of the platform, it someways that is a turn off. There is something to be said for consistency. I like knowing that any app I download will work with my device and was designed with my device's screen, resolution and capabilities in mind. Everything seems integrated. Everything seems to fit. Everything seems made to work with and for the device (except their notifications system...it sucks badly). In a word, the iPhone and iOS is more polished.
Android always seems like it is a work in progress, almost like the famous google perpetual betas. It almost seems experimental. Whereas BB always seems to far behind the cutting edge. BB doesn't seem to have any 'fun' to them.
If I were to ever switch, it would probably come down to HP webOS, Android or Windows 7 Phone, in that order.
